I really thought I had reviewed the most classic and iconic mascara of all time. But recently discovered I hadn't. I've reviewed remix versions..but never the OG . Maybelline Great Lash was the very first mascara I ever bought. I think I was in the 6th or 7th grade. I faithfully applied it every day and had no idea what the point was. I didn't know what mascara was supposed to do. I think I only bought it once though and then...I guess at some point I moved on to other brands.
Maybelline claims:
After 40 years, Great Lash is still America’s favorite mascara.
Maybelline Great Lash Mascara is your timeless go-to for natural-looking volume.
Small brush, big control. The small mascara brush is easy to control to target hard-to-reach corners and long and short lashes alike for buildable volume for every lash.
Lash-doubling formula. Our lash-doubling mascara formula lengthens and conditions lashes for an easy, everyday makeup look.
Hypoallergenic mascara. The hypoallergenic formula is ophthalmologist tested, allergy tested, and safe for contact lens wearers.
4 natural-looking mascara shades. Choose from Dark Brown, Brownish Black, Very Black, or Blackest Black for a volumizing mascara shade that suits your natural lash color.
Once you swipe on Great Lash Washable Mascara, you’ll see why there's been billions of Great Lashes since 1971.
Made in USA
I have used tons of mascara from Maybelline. They make great mascara. But Great Lash is not one of them. You can get much, much better for the price. It's a water based mascara that's supposed to be easily washable, It's been around since 1971...though I'm sure the formula has been changed and it's not what you might have bought in 1971.
It comes in the easily recognizable pink and green packaging. Classic. Although I think the old tubes look better than what is being sold now.
Before Great Lash- there was Ultra Lash from the 60's which I just found out about. I thought Great Last was the first mascara in this format. And even before that the brand was responsible for the world's first mascara all the way back in 1913.

But I think this is the worst mascara I have ever tried and it's going in the trash after I review it. I think a better name for it would be Bad Lash. Or Sad Lash. Even Make You Mad Lash.
It's so wet. It doesn't build up. It never dries. It does a whole lot of nothing for my lashes. No volume, no length. My main issues with this is it always seems to get in my eyes and then my eyes HURT for days after. It stings my eyes for the rest of the day and causes so many problems. Happened to my eye the first time I used it. And then again yesterday- so now I'm over it.
It's so easy to get into the eye due to how wet it is. I like to start at the roots but with the problems this has caused me I am scared to start at the roots and it's pretty much guaranteed to drip into my eyes. Usually I hate throwing anything away and will try to work with products and find other ways to use them. But this is not worth it.
Usually with this mascara type- I would try to wait until it dries out but I can't keep messing up my eyes.
The only positive thing I have to say about it is how black it looks. It's also a bit more on the "glossy" side which I don't normally notice in any other mascara I have bought.
I almost forgot to take about the brush- which is so tiny. I really don't like the brush. Nor the way the handle feels when I'm applying it.
So into the bin it will go.
And now a look at some of the ads- which I always find fun.
Also a commercial- the very obviously fake lashes are taking me out.









